A definition of Documentary Art: Szarkowski, Gedney

Alec Soth’s blog led me over to the notebooks of William Gedney online at Duke and to a nice definition of documentary art that Gedney quotes in one of his notebooks from John Swarkowski:

“A documentary art work must appear to be unmanipulated, literal, clear, complete, and easy; it must not allow its art to show; it must not be obviously elegant or ornamental; it must at least pretend objectivity.” — link (bottom left page)

That’s a clear definition, and good enough. Cuts away some from what could be considered documentary art, but doesn’t get too specific, which would only lead to the trouble of being, you know, too specific, and leaving out what could be considered documentary art. Better to define what something isn’t, rather than what it should be.

0 Responses to “A definition of Documentary Art: Szarkowski, Gedney”


  1. No Comments

Leave a Reply




  • Subscribe via Feedburner
  • Subscribe in Yahoo
  • Add to Google

Asides

»

Mcnamara at PopPhoto sez their lens tests are the best cause they use an optical bench. Consistent objectivity. I’ll keep that in mind next time I read a lens review.

# 0
» PicLens toggles online images to fullscreen. For Mac (Safari only). Click on a picture from Flickr, Photobucket, Facebook, Google, Yahoo, or Ask.com image search, and get a fullscreen image instantly. Can then cycle through images in fullscreen mode.
# 0
» Interesting NYTimes article on Jerome Liebling, photographer and filmmaker. Tribute to him tonight at the Museum of Television and Radio in NYC.
# 0
» flickr and Google Earth mashed up. Wow.
# 0
» Eddie Adams workshop report. That’s 50 photo students, and 50 young photo professionals all together for a workshop. Second year its all digital.
# 0
» Alternative processes site. Argyrotypes, Bromoils, Gum Bichromates, Wetplate Collodions. Back to the roots. Go roots.
# 0
» Wanyne Yang interview with Kitra Cahana on his blog, Eight Diagrams. She won 3rd place Picture of the Year. Go Kitra.
# 0
» Weegee photo on cover of Time magazine. Big rear-end of an elephant. Go Weegee.
# 0
» More sample M8 pictures on a Hong Kong Leica forum.
# 0
» Photoshop LAB black and white conversion Martin Fuchs gives a nice explanation of his PS action (download is free). As good as it gets without buying a plugin.
# 0
» Martin Evening reviews Adobe Lightroom’s develope module Quick update on what’s new in ‘Beta 4′. Go Martin.
# 0